Leon J. Podles :: DIALOGUE

At one point in my peregrinations, I drove from Bozeman to Kalispell. The radio stations offered three choices: Country and Western, Christian, and Christian Country and Western. I listened to each as long as I could stand it: Rollin in my Sweet Baby’s Arms (when does the mail train come back?), Yes We’ll Gather by [...]

[Read more →]

Commonweal is having a discussion in the decades-old topic “Why Catholics Can’t (or Won’t) Sing.” 
The lack of singing at Mass is a symptom that the liturgical renewal was not a popular movement: it was developed by a small group of enthusiasts and scholars and imposed on the laity without any consultation. Catholics have a strong [...]

[Read more →]

The liturgical wars continue over the new proposed new translation.  
I have noticed that the current translation is marked by a preference for general language which obscures the biblical references. The Roman liturgy is a tissue of quotations and allusions to the Bible, and biblical language tends to be concrete rather than abstract: how beautiful are [...]

[Read more →]

As someone suggested in the comments, it might be better from a moral point of view to have the priest and the people facing the same way. 
I think that main problem with having the priest face the people is that it feeds narcissism to be aware that all eyes are on you, and too many [...]

[Read more →]

The discussion over at dotCommonweal reveals at attitude toward marriage that it is private affair which the couple should be able to celebrate in their own way. 
In the Western Church, following Roman law, the essence of marriage is considered the mutual consent of the spouses. The priest is only a witness, and his presence was [...]

[Read more →]

Bishop R. Nickless of Sioux City has written a letter to his diocese: Ecclesia Semper Reformanda.
 
In it he denounces the false method of interpreting the Second Vatican Council: 

On the one hand, there is an interpretation that I would call “a hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture,” it has frequently availed itself of the sympathies of the [...]

[Read more →]

Priests who crack jokes during the Divine Liturgy are on my little list, and none of them will be missed. I know that priests have long been given the bad advice to begin the sermon with a joke to crack the ice with the congregation – but a sermon is not public speaking at a [...]

[Read more →]

As the Catholic bishops in the United States are discovering, it is much harder to tighten discipline than to loosen it, as any teacher or parent could have told them. For decades, over a generation, the bishops did nothing to publicly rebuke or discipline Catholic politicians who want abortion to be legal. Catholics got the [...]

[Read more →]

In 1912, a member of the Church and Religion Forward Movement complained that trained choirs were replacing congregational singing and were becoming a form of religious entertainment. He added 

What is worse than that is this: That in this tendency to aestheticism, we have brought within the pale of the church—may we blush for it—a kind [...]

[Read more →]