Leon J. Podles :: DIALOGUE
A Discussion of Faith, Family, and Culture
RSS
  • Home
  • Archives
  • About
  • Podles.org

More on the Death Saint

March 30, 2009 in death, law enforcement, Mexico 1 Comment Tags: Aztecs, Mexico, Santa Muertem syncretism

Santa Muerte and “Bishop” David Romo Guillén

The faithful followers of Santa Muerte, the Death Saint, are unhappy that the government destroyed the shrines they had built on public land (see blog below).

One bishop, according to the Washington Post, agreed with them

But the destruction enraged Death Saint church leaders, including archbishop David Romo who in a homily Sunday called on followers across Mexico to hold demonstrations against the demolitions.

“It was both an open act of religious intolerance and an act of arrogance,” Romo said. “We are entering a stage of religious and governmental terrorism.”

He called on followers to stage protest marches during Easter week, including a potentially provocative Easter Sunday march to the Basilica of the Virgin of Guadalupe, the country’s widely-revered Roman Catholic patroness.

A previous report indicated that he said

“We are being persecuted,” said Catholic Bishop David Romo, who has become the black sheep of Mexico’s Catholic church for leading services to the bejeweled, scythe-wielding Santa Muerte, or Saint Death, in the rough Mexico City neighborhood of Tepito.

However Romo, despite inaccurate news reports, is not a Catholic, but rather a self-styled bishop of a traditionalist church, whose traditionalism seems to include pagan worship (Spero):

Cult spokesman David Romo Guillén, who styles himself as a bishop,[of] “The Mexico-US Tridentine Catholic Church” or “The Traditional Catholic Mex-USA Church.”

Mexico has native religious beliefs that pre-date the 1521 Spanish conquest and the arrival of the Catholic faith. Aztec and Mayan art and imagery are replete with images of death in the form of skull-adorned temples and deathly idols. Human sacrifice was offered by Mexicans’ ancestors to placate pagan gods and ensure the fertility of the earth. Before the Conquest, as many as 60,000 human lives were offered to the Aztec deities in as little as four days. That cult of death was sometimes personified by “Mictlantecuhtli” – a god who is represented as a skeleton or flayed man. Mass baptisms of Native Americans and catechisms in native languages offered by the first Spanish missionaries in the 1500s were not enough to wipe away generations of non-Christian, non-Western beliefs.

Mictlantecuhtl

The real Catholic archdiocese has a different take:

Hugo Valdemar Romero, spokesman for the Archdiocese of Mexico, said the Roman Catholic Church was in no way involved in the demolitions. But he added that “it is no secret that this (Saint Death) religious organization is associated with drug traffickers and organized crime … it is not only superstitious, but diabolical.”

Romero has previously admitted the Catholic Church was in part at fault:

Lamenting the failure the Catholic Church has had in adequately addressing the needs of his flock, a spokesman for the Archdiocese of Mexico City said last month that “Catholics are easy prey for the snares of imposters because of the deficient evangelization and religious formation we (the hierarchy) have provided to the faithful.”

Elementary Christian doctrine is a protection against superstition, whether in Mexico, Africa, or the United States (although our superstitions, e. g. Reiki, are not as colorful).

Leave a Comment

Seventy Years Later

March 29, 2009 in Responsibility, Spain 2 Comments Tags: Franco, repentance, Spanish Civil War

Der Spiegel notes this anniversary: The thousand bloody days of the Spanish Civil War ended in March 1939 when Franco marched into Madrid. The killing was not over.

Probably 200,000 human beings were killed in the name of Franco’s name in the Civil War in in the years after the war. But in their area of influence the Republicans had 38,000 political opponents murdered among whom were 6,800 priests, whom they wrongly believed to be on Franco’s side. And if such numbers are only estimates, they still have explosive force: Even until the present Spanish society is troubled and polarized, even until the present are mass graves and the bones of political opponents sought. For the Spanish the Civil War is even after 70 years an open wound.

Both sides committed atrocities in the Civil War; Franco kept up the killing afterward. All that can be said for him is that he probably killed fewer people than the Communists would have killed, if they had come to power.

Like many historical traumas, the wounds of the Spanish Vivil War remains unhealed. The French have never come to terms with the violence of the Revolution, or with Vichy collaboration with the Nazis. The Germans have not fully come to terms with the Nazi era. Russia keeps retreating from a confrontation with the evils of the Communist era. The Catholic Church turns its face away from the sexual abuse scandal. And so on. Our instinct is to turn our face away from horrors, but without confrontation and repentance there is no healing.

Leave a Comment

Music Hath Charms

March 29, 2009 in Psychology, Uncategorized No Comments Tags: Music therapy

Everyone recognizes that music can affect the listener’s mood – that is why most people listen to music. Can music also either directly or through the mood affect the body? That is more debatable, but some therapists are convinced it can. The New York Times reports:

“Listening to finer music and attending concerts on a consistent basis makes your real age about four years younger,” Dr. Michael F. Roizen — the chief wellness officer of the Wellness Institute at the Cleveland Clinic, said recently. “Whether that’s due to stress relief or other properties, we see decreases in all-cause mortality, reflecting slower aging of arteries as well as cancer-related and environmental factors. Attending sports events like soccer or football offers none of these benefits.”

Therapists are experimenting with specially-composed music that is adopted ot different problems: depression, insomnia, anxiety, etc.

Stefan Koelsch, “a senior research fellow in neurocognition of music and language at the University of Sussex in Brighton, England,” has great hopes:

“Physiologically, it’s perfectly plausible that music would affect not only psychiatric conditions but also endocrine, autonomic and autoimmune disorders,” he said. “I can’t say music is a pill to abolish these diseases. But my vision is that we can come up with things to help. This work is so important. So many pills have horrible side effects, both physiological and psychological. Music has no side effects, or no harmful ones.”

One side effect is very useful. I have been surprised to hear baroque music playing at various train stations and other unlikely places. I then learned that researchers had discovered that punks hate baroque music: to a punk, Haydn is like a fingernail on a blackboard. To clear out the thugs, play Bach.

Leave a Comment

Rationing Jail Time

March 28, 2009 in guilt, law enforcement, Responsibility 1 Comment Tags: fraud, jail, Poulsen

White-collar perpetrators of fraud are a popular target of rage, with good reason. I have lost a substantial amount to fraud over the years, including some to Bernie Madoff – and I’m not even Jewish. It is therefore extremely satisfying to see such crooks enjoy the hospitality of the Department of Corrections.

The New York Times reports:

Nearly seven years after National Century Financial Enterprises collapsed in a $2.9 billion fraud, its founder, Lance K. Poulsen, was sentenced to 30 years in prison on Friday in one of the harshest white-collar punishments in history.

Poulsen targeted health-care:

Mr. Poulsen was convicted in October of leading a vast fraud as chief executive of National Century, a company based in Dublin, Ohio, that provided financing for hundreds of clinics, hospitals and other health care providers. The company’s fall in 2002 contributed to the bankruptcies of 275 health care facilities.

Mr. Poulsen is already in jail

Mr. Poulsen, 65, is already serving a 10-year sentence for trying to bribe the main witness against him in the case. His sentence will run concurrently with the sentence for witness tampering.

Judges listen to the voice of the people:

Mr. Marbley’s decision signals that federal judges could begin imposing harsher sentences for white-collar crime in response to the rise in public outrage over corporate fraud after the discovery of Bernard L. Madoff’s multibillion-dollar Ponzi scheme. The sentence for Mr. Poulsen exceeds the 25 years given to Bernard J. Ebbers, the former chief executive of WorldCom, and the 24 years given to Jeffrey K. Skilling, the former Enron chief.

Recently I chatted with Michael Timmis, the head of Prison Fellowship International. He said that poor criminal who knocks over the 7-11 for $250 gets 20 years. When this guy sees Madoff in his penthouse, he wonders whether our justice system has any justice in it. So it looks like a good idea to send the fraudsters to jail.

BUT

Jail cells are limited in number and a prisoner costs on the average $35,000 a year to maintain. The United States already has a prison population that dwarfs other advanced countries. Because of budget constraints in the current downturn, states are speeding up parole hearings and trying to keep down their jail populations.

As much as it pains me, I think that if the choice is between keeping a white-collar criminal in jail and a violent criminal in jail, I would opt for the violent criminal. The guy who knocked over the 7-11 probably used a gun; even Madoff never threatened to physically harm anyone.

White-collar crimes are treated as civil matters in Europe, which is generally laxer than the United States about crime (see the blog about Swensson below). Fraudsters should be stripped of every penny that have or might someday get, and reduced to absolute penury, but I am afraid that we may have to come up to some alternative to jail, unless we can discover some way of getting these fraudsters to put their talents to work and paying for their own keep while in prison. Perhaps they could work for Tim Geithner at the Department of the Treasury (see Springtime for Hitler).

Leave a Comment

Episcopal Foot in Mouth Disease

March 28, 2009 in Anti-Semitism 3 Comments Tags: Anti-Semitism, Ddaeus Grings, Holocaust Denial

Archbishop Dadeus Grings

Catholic clerics have not learned that one must be ultra-cautious in making any statement about the Holocaust. Jews are understandably sensitive about anything that tends to minimize their unimaginable suffering.

Archbishop Dadeus Grings of Porto Alegre in Brazil has not learned this lesson.

According to reports here, here, here, and here he has said

The Jews talk about six million people killed. But how many Catholics were victims of the Holocaust? They were 22 million in all.

There were not 22 million killed in the Nazi camps; there were 22 million, probably many more, civilian victims of the war, and I suspect the biggest group of civilian victims was among the Slavic Orthodox. Among Catholics, Poles suffered terribly, and then probably Germans, but Catholics were not the biggest civilian group of victims, either in numbers or proportion.

Grings added

Jews say they were the main victims of the Holocaust, the biggest victims were the gypsies, because they were exterminated.

The gypsies (Roma) were also a target of the Nazis, and it is possible that a greater proportion of gypsies than of Jews was killed by the Nazis– I have not seen any analysis. But the gypsies were not exterminated; there are numerous gypsies (who seem to be mostly Catholic – of a sort) in Europe.

But Grings really inserted and pushed his foot firmly into his mouth when he added

Os judeus têm a propaganda do mundo

The Jews control the world press.

Grings has been at it before. In 2003 he said “one million” Jews were killed by the Nazis:

Sem entrar na questão de número das vítimas, que tem muito de ideológica, é preciso reconhecer, como historicamente comprovado, que o nazismo provocou em torno de 22 milhões de mortes, sendo que os judeus participam desta cifra com cerca de 1 milhão. Portanto a grande vítima do nazismo não foram os judeus, mas os cristãos.

Grings is repeating in 2009 what he said in 2003: Christians, not Jews, were the primary victims of the Holocaust. This is simply not true, and Grings, like Williamson, is providing respectability to anti-Semites. A comment on one Catholic blog was:

It takes courage to speak the truth and this Archbishop has added his name to those like Bishop Williamson who seek the truth and fight against the evils of this world. I have much respect for all of them.

Leave a Comment

The Dangers of Popular Piety

March 27, 2009 in Uncategorized 5 Comments Tags: drug trafficers, Mexico, popular piety, Santa Muerte

The AP had a curious story about Mexico:

Officials in Nuevo Laredo have destroyed more than 35 statues dedicated to a “Death Saint” popular with drug traffickers.

The statues, most depicting a robe-covered skeleton resembling the Grim Reaper, lined highways and roads in and around the Mexican city on the border with Texas. One of the statues was located at the base of an international bridge linking Mexico and the U.S.

A few months ago The New Yorker had an article about Mexican drug traffickers and their religious beliefs:

On the first day of every month, at the Tepito metro stop in downtown Mexico City, a new breed of pilgrim can be observed inching his way on his knees out of the stop and down a filthy market street, and cradling in his arms, babylike, a plastic figure of Death—or Holy Death, La Santa Muerte, as the pilgrims refer to the robed skeleton, who carries, variously, a scythe, a sceptre, a set of scales, or a globe in her (sometimes his) hands. There were dozens of these effigies, borne by crawling men in their teens or early twenties. Tattooed and gaunt, they were dressed in black T-shirts with the sleeves ripped off and wore chains around their necks and silver skulls, like brass knuckles, on their fingers.

Their goal was some four blocks distant, in the heart of Tepito, a legendary neighborhood that in the centuries since the Spanish Conquest has remained stubbornly insubordinate. Venders were everywhere along the pilgrims’ path, hawking T-shirts and baseball caps and medals decorated with the Santa Muerte.

The shrine of the Holy Death is just blocks away from a compound of low-income housing where, in 2007, Mexico City police conducted a full-scale assault in search of drugs, weapons, and other illegal goods. Enriqueta Romero Romero, known as Queta, or Quetita, set up the shrine on this spot seven years ago after one of her sons, who was himself a devotee of La Santa, made her a gift of the skeleton. The bewigged saint now stands in a glass case, elaborately robed and veiled according to Queta’s inspiration—sometimes in rainbow gauze, sometimes in white lace. Queta and her son also more or less invented the 8 P.M. “Rosary” that is held on the first of every month, and draws thousands of the faithful, including the skull-ringed young men who, at a guess, make a paltry living running many kinds of errands for the lords of Tepito. Queta says the skeleton is feminine—the Niña Blanca, or White Girl-Child—and that those who say there is such a thing as a He-Death, and that one should have both on one’s home altar, so the two can meet and marry, are charlatans. Queta is small, sixtyish, and bustling; she blows kisses at her Niña every other sentence and has a benevolent smile for everyone. But her gaze can narrow with suspicion in an alarming fashion, and one has the sense that she can summon dangerous help to her side very quickly.

The Santa Muerte had been hanging around the fringes of popular belief in Tepito and other raffish neighborhoods for decades—Queta says that she learned to pray to her from her aunt—but thanks to Queta her cult now extends throughout Mexico City and far beyond. There are, by Queta’s count, two thousand shrines like hers in Mexico, and who knows if she is including the charlatans in her tally? (The cult is known for the drug traffickers’ devotion to it, but it certainly embraces a far larger number of believers.) Hers, at any rate, was the first public shrine, and it holds a cathedral-like status for worshippers like Felicitas Castillo, a young woman who for the past five years has travelled once a month from the city of Xalapa, two hundred miles away, in order to offer the “Utmost Holy Death” roses and a mariachi serenade. On the day that I visited the shrine, the musicians played ranchera songs that are normally dedicated to the Virgin of Guadalupe, and Castillo provided an answer heard many times when I asked the faithful what they prayed for. “I don’t ask for much,” Castillo said. “Health for my family, work.” This is an answer recommended by Queta, who doesn’t think that one should bargain with Death or be greedy. But the following afternoon, as the time for the Rosary drew near and worshippers pressed more and more tightly into the narrow street where the shrine is situated, one crawling young man said that he was praying for his ex-girlfriend, who lived in another state, to let him see his five-month-old daughter. A woman wanted the holy figure to help her get over the suicide, last year, of her fourteen-year-old son.

Along the edges of the packed street, young men took quick snorts of glue and sometimes wept. A thin tattooed and pierced man with terrible skin was the only one of the many young toughs present who was willing to talk to me, and his amiability may have had something to do with the fact that he had just absent-mindedly assembled a joint about the size of a Robusto and was now wreathed in its smoke. The Holy Death had restored to him the love of the excruciatingly shy woman at his side, the man said, and he was now Death’s devotee forever. At the front of the crowd, banks of flowers to rival those laid at Princess Diana’s grave paid tribute to the skeleton. Half hidden by the flowers was a large, clear plastic death figure, and behind it was a sound system at which one of Queta’s sons would soon lead the Rosary. Behind that, Queta cackled in answer to a question. Yes, it was true that the Catholic Church disapproved of her “Little Skinny One,” she said. “But have you noticed how empty their churches are?”

Queta’s genius has been to create out of her Catholic faith an inclusive syncretic ritual: a Rosary, which is recited complete with Hail Marys and the Lord’s Prayer; special prayers for those in jail; and a culminating, quasi-Pentecostal moment when the faithful all lift their effigy to Heaven to “charge it with energy.” It is a cult, Queta says, accurately, that does not discriminate. A Catholic priest might extend grudging absolution to those who confess that they have just sold several grams of crystal meth to a bunch of twelve-year-olds, but only at Queta’s Rosary can you be blessed on a monthly basis without the matter of how you earn a living ever coming up.

Modern scholars often lament how the “orthodox” managed to kick out of Christianity all sorts of popular religious movements, and how the “orthodox” oppose the full acculturation of Christianity into various cultures. This acculturation of Christianity into the drug culture of Mexico perhaps should give these scholars pause.

Also those who have nostalgia for the pagan religions that Christianity replaced and sometimes obliterated should reflect upon the Aztec gods and their thirst for human blood.

Leave a Comment

Killers as Doctors

March 24, 2009 in clergy sex abuse scandal, guilt, law enforcement, Medical ethics, Responsibility, sexual abuse, Vatican 1 Comment Tags: crime, Karl Helge Hampus Svensson, punishment, Sweden

The future Dr. Svensson of Sweden

One possible source of the Vatican’s lax attitude to sexual abusers in the clergy is that the Vatican is staffed by Europeans who consider America’s harsh punishments of crime barbaric.

Sweden, the New York Times reports, has a convicted neo-Nazi murderer in medical school.

Mr. Svensson…was convicted in the 1999 hate murder of a trade union worker and was paroled after serving 6 ½ years of an 11-year sentence — a typical penalty for murder in Sweden.

His sentence by American standards was lenient.

In contrast with the United States, Swedish laws and customs are sympathetic to released offenders, saying that once they have served their time they should be treated like ordinary citizens.

Although Swensson

has not publicly expressed regret for his crime

one should not be harsh on him.

A Swedish medical student opines:

Mr. Svensson should be allowed to become a doctor. “Who is to say that he might not become a great doctor, even if it in some ways would feel wrong or awkward to have a murderer for a colleague?” he asked. “It is not fair to have preconceptions about his character.”

Even if they are murderers.

Although the entrance to the state-financed slots at the medicals school are extremely competitive (2.603 applicants for 100 positions), the board that interviewed Swenson was not curious about his background:

The disclosures about his past proved deeply embarrassing to the institute. Among other things, two senior faculty members on the admissions committee that interviewed him failed to ask for an explanation of the six-and-a-half-year gap in his résumé, the period he was in prison.

So they admitted him, although there were repercussions:

A year ago, Sweden’s most prestigious medical school found itself in an international uproar after it unknowingly admitted a student who was a Nazi sympathizer and a convicted murderer, then scrambled to find a way to expel him.

The medical school decided that being a murderer was not enough; he had also falsified his records, and that was a serious matter, although not everyone agreed

Eventually he was expelled; but that is not the end of it.

The 33-year-old student, Karl Helge Hampus Svensson, having been banished from the medical school of the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm on the ground that he falsified his high school records, has now been admitted to a second well-known medical school — Uppsala, Sweden’s oldest university.

The murderer is in medical school; the court records about the murder victim have conveniently and mysteriously disappeared, like many pages from the court records of priest-abusers in Boston.

In another embarrassing twist, a Swedish newspaper reported last month that much of the verdict and court files regarding Bjorn Soderberg, Mr. Svensson’s murder victim, had been cut out or replaced with blank pages. The police said they had been unable to find a culprit.

If murderers can make good doctors, a fortiori sexual criminals can:

And in still another case, a 24-year-old medical student at Lund University was convicted last April of raping a 14-year-old boy while he slept. A district court sentenced the student to two years in prison, but a higher court reduced the sentence to two years’ probation and medical therapy.

When the dean at Lund sought to expel the student, a national board that reviews expulsions blocked the action, saying that although the man had committed a serious crime, he was not considered a threat to people or property.

Doctors, even more than priests, have contact with extremely vulnerable people. But Europeans shy away from the harsh attitude to criminals that Americans have, and perhaps that explains the Vatican’s attitude to the clerical criminals that infested the Church in the United States.

Leave a Comment

Population Bust in Russia

March 23, 2009 in demography, sexual abuse No Comments

The headline of the NYT article says it all: Its Population Falling, Russia Beckons Its Children Home.

The United Nations predicts that the country will fall to 116 million people by 2050, from 141 million now, an 18 percent decline, largely because of a low birthrate and poor health habits.

Abortion and contraception are entrenched in Russia, and even baby bonuses haven’t slowed the population decline.

The Russian government is therefore looking to Russians beyond its borders.

Moscow has spent $300 million in the past two years to get the repatriation program started, and officials estimated that more than 25 million people were eligible, many of them ethnic Russians who found themselves living in former Soviet republics after the Soviet collapse in 1991.

Even Old Believers who fled to Brazil are being contacted.

But not much success so far:

So far, only 10,300 people have moved back under the government repatriation program, which has faced criticism that it is overly bureaucratic and unpersuasive.

Leave a Comment

Benedict and Joseph

March 19, 2009 in clericalism, Narcissism, Vatican 1 Comment Tags: clericalism, Pope Benedict, St. Joseph

Benedict, when he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, eyed the cult of personality in the Catholic Church (including the cult surrounding John Paul II) with a hairy eyeball. He did not want a cult of personality when he became Pope, and his sometimes unconsidered remarks and actions have guaranteed that there is no cult of personality for Papa Benedetto.

In Africa, Benedict, according to CNA, gave an address to priests and made two important points:

He continued speaking to the priests saying they “cannot occupy center stage; [they are] a servant, a humble instrument pointing to Christ, who offers himself in sacrifice for the salvation of the world.” This, Benedict taught, is how Origen understood Joseph and Jesus’ relationship to be, “Joseph understood that Jesus was superior to him even as he submitted to him, and, knowing the superiority of his charge, he commanded him with respect and moderation.”

That is, the priest (and the bishops and the pope) are not supposed to attract attention to themselves, but be mere pointers to the true Savior, Jesus Christ. Would that pompous ritualists and would-be Las Vegas comedians who use the Mass as their stage would follow his advice! They won’t.

Priests should realize they are often in the position of Joseph who had fatherly authority over Jesus. In the flock committed to them there are often people far, far superior to the priest in holiness of life and growth in spirituality. The priest (and bishop and the pope), because of his office, has an essential role in governing the Church, but he is almost always governing people often far better than he is. This humbling thought should cause church authorities to exercise their office with care and discretion, in a spirit of service. One can always hope.

Leave a Comment

The Catholic Art Scene in Florida

March 14, 2009 in Florida, Narcissism 1 Comment Tags: Ave Maria University, Tom Monaghan

My daughter, a painter who has fled Florida for a northern art school, is visiting us in Naples and noticed the progress of the arts in the town of Ave Maria, Florida. The Naples Daily News reports:

The Ave Maria Gallery and History Exhibit has opened in La Piazza, the town center of Ave Maria, a community and university at Oil Well and Camp Keais roads in eastern Collier County.

“We believe visitors to our town will very much enjoy this gallery,” said Project Manager Blake Gable. “It provides interesting perspective on Ave Maria’s history.”

The gallery displays a variety of archival items that relate to Ave Maria University and its founder, Tom Monaghan, who also was the founder of Domino’s Pizza and owner of the Detroit Tigers.

Included are:

– The founding of a university: Photographs spanning the building of the university from the tomato fields that preceded it to today, as well as the construction of the Oratory, from its first sketches to its completion.

– Fine Art Gallery with artwork for viewing and sale.

– A tribute to the late Pope John Paul II: A bust of Pope John Paul II, a chair that was custom built for his historic 1987 visit to Detroit, plus photographs of the Mass at the Pontiac Silver Dome in Detroit and more.

– Detroit Tiger baseball archives: The 1984 World Series trophy, one of Al Kaline’s Gold Glove Awards, a Joe DiMaggio designed baseball glove chair and assorted signed memorabilia.

– A brief history of Domino’s Pizza: The sign from the first store, plus archival photos and historical information.

– Model of Frank Lloyd Wright House: An architect’s rendition of the Robie House in Chicago.

The exhibit, which will continue to grow and evolve, is at 5072 Annunciation Circle, No. 103 next to Tropical Smoothie.

Leave a Comment

Maciel – Four Possibilities

March 13, 2009 in clergy sex abuse scandal, Maciel, Narcissism, sexual abuse, Vatican 12 Comments Tags: Legion of Christ, Maciel

The Vatican and the Legion of Christ have decided to maintain a discrete silence about Maciel. Perhaps a further statement will be forthcoming, as promised, or perhaps the Vatican and the Legion count on the short attention span of the public.

The Legion has admitted that Maciel fathered a child in his old age and was leading a double life. Maciel went to his grave without admitting any guilt. He let the Legion portray him as a wrongly-persecuted saint.

When the Vatican told Maciel to retire to a life of prayer and penance, it showed it believed at least some of the allegations that he had molested seminarians.

There are further allegations and rumors, which I list in roughly descending order of probability:

– That Maciel absolved his sexual partners during confession

– That Maciel misused Legion money

– That Maciel led a luxurious life

– That Maciel used narcotics

– That Maciel became the lover of several rich women to extract money from them

– That Maciel was involved in narcotraffic

– That the mother of the daughter was only 15 when Maciel impregnated her.

The admitted double life and the certain molestations of seminarians are bad enough; the others simply compound the crimes.

From the admissions and allegations about Maciel I have come up with four possibilities, in descending order of seriousness:

1. He was a false prophet who was sent to deceive if possible even the elect. Germain Grisez leans in this direction.

2. He was a charismatic psychopath, totally lacking in empathy for the pain he was causing, and he constructed the Legion to indulge his vices.

3. He was a pathological narcissist, not completely lacking in empathy, but determined to keep everyone centered upon his personality and thereby control everyone. His altruism was in the service of his narcissism: he did good things so that he would be the center of attention.

4. He was himself seriously damaged by abuse and compartmentalized his personality, as men all too easily do. All his good work was in one part of his life; then there was another, sealed-off compartment that contained his sexuality.

I don’t know, and perhaps no human being alive knows, which of these possibilities is closest to the truth. Maciel did a lot of harm, whatever the cause, but clearly one’s attitude to him would change if he himself had somehow been a victim.

There were enough clues over the years to alert authorities in the Vatican that something was wrong, there was at the very minimum too much of a cult of personality and too rigid a control of members. But no one acted until Benedict became pope; he knew something was seriously wrong, and at least took some action. Was it enough? Those who said that Maciel abused them are still being called liars by some members of the Legion.

Members of the Legion want to think that Maciel was simply a sinner, that his one fling showed he had human weaknesses. But clearly Maciel’s personality was severely damaged and distorted to the point that the Legion, which was set up to reflect his personality, itself must suffer from serious distortions.

Can a religious congregation be founded by an unrepentant sinner? Who would want to join a congregation founded by a child molester? But what is the Church to do with the Legion? I would suggest a spiritual Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The assets of the Legion, its members, properties, and endowments, should be distributed to other congregations in the Church.

Leave a Comment

A Tale of Two Chapels

March 11, 2009 in Church Architecture, Narcissism 5 Comments Tags: Ave Maria University, Church Architecture, Duncan Stroik, Thoams Aquinas College, Thomas Monaghan

On the West Coast a new college chapel:

Chapel of Our Lady of the Most Holy Trinity, Thomas Aquinas College, Ojai, California. Architect: Professor Duncan Stroik, School of Architecture, University of Notre Dame. Cost $22 million.

On the East Coast, a new university oratory

Oratory, Ave Maria College, Ave Maria, Collier County, Florida. Architect: Thomas Monaghan, founder of Domino’s Pizza. Cost $24 million.

Leave a Comment

A Demographic Bounce in Germany

March 10, 2009 in demography, Germany, Population No Comments Tags: birth rate, demography, Germany

Allan Carlson has emphasized that a government can’t buy a higher birthrate. Generous family allowances may encourage couples to have their children earlier in life, but the ultimate birthrate is not affected.

This seems to have happened in Germany. The German government is concerned about the abysmal birthrate in Germany and increased family allowances. Der Spiegel reports

A drop in the number of births in Germany during the months of October and November suggests there may have been a birth rate decline in the country during 2008, despite lavish government benefits for new parents.

For months, it looked like Germany might have put a stop to its shrinking birth rate. Indeed, in 2007, the country actually managed a bit of population growth. And, with a fast graying population that will be knocking on the door of the local pension office in the next few decades, it was high time, too.

But a reversal of Germany’s demographic fortunes has proven to be a mirage.

Birth rates reflect confidence in the future, and ultimately some sort of faith in Providence. Economic hard times will further de[press the birth rate and increase the burden of pensions, which in turn will lower the income of workers, leading to a lower birth rate, and so on. Euthanasia or massive immigration are the obvious solutions; Holland has already adopted the former to control health care costs.

Leave a Comment

The Decline and Fall of American Catholicism

March 9, 2009 in Uncategorized 5 Comments

The American Religious Identification Survey has come out. Americans of European descent leave the Catholic Church at about the same rate that Episcopalians leave the Episcopal Church. The Catholic numbers stay the same because the gap is filled by Latinos. Because immigration in Europe is Moslem rather than Catholic, the decline of Catholicism is more apparent there.

A handful of Catholics leave for more liberal churches; more leave for conservative evangelical and Pentecostal churches, but most drift off into indifference. The decline of Catholicism in New England is especially striking. Phil Lawler has described it in The Faithful Departed.

Faith is not a matter of mere knowledge. But the sad state of catechetics for the past two generations must have contributed to the decline. My family offered to fund a study to see whether Catholic school children in Baltimore at least knew the basic vocabulary of Catholicism; the archdiocese did not even reply to our letters offering money; the bureaucrats did not want to know the truth.

The disruptive reforms also must have caused much of the loss. Catholicism was for many people a matter of habit – a good habit, but mostly habit. When the mass was changed and almost all popular devotions suppressed, the habit was broken.

Indifferentism was also a result of the renunciation of triumphalist Catholicism. Catholics were warned there was no salvation outside the juridical boundaries of the Roman Catholic Church. That certainty was eroded and then rejected, and the Church has not found a convincing way of presenting the doctrine that the Catholic Church is indeed willed by God, although He can work outside its visible boundaries.

The sexual scandals also helped undermine faith. William Lobdell lost his faith in God after he covered the sexual scandals for the Los Angeles Times. He recounts the painful story in Losing My Religion: How I Lost My Faith Reporting on Religion in America — and Found Unexpected Peace. I will have more to say about this book later.

The situation in Africa and the Far East is different, but America and Europe still provide the financial and intellectual leadership in the Church, and troubles here will eventually hurt the Church in poorer countries.

Leave a Comment

Maciel and Donatism

March 5, 2009 in Maciel, Uncategorized 10 Comments Tags: Donatism, Maciel

As heresy fanciers will remember, Donatism was a North African heresy that denied that sacraments administered by serious sinful priests were valid.

Some bishops were accused of handing over (tradere) the Scriptures to pagan authorities during the last great persecution. These bishops were called traditores, handers-over, or traitors.

The Donatists set up their own hierarchy and rebaptized any Catholic who joined them. For Augustine schism was a very serious sin, and the Donatist denial of the validity of baptism unless it was performed by a Donatist was heresy. Augustine spent much energy arguing with them, and finally relied upon Imperial laws to force them back into the Catholic Church.

He wrote Letter 208 to Felicia, a Donatist consecrated virgin who had become a Catholic, perhaps by Imperial force. She was scandalized by corrupt members of the Catholic hierarchy.

Augustine wrote to her:

In order, therefore, that we may remain in unity and not abandon the threshing floor of the Lord when we are offended by the scandals from the chaff but may rather remain as grain until the end of the winnowing and endure the straw that is crushed by the strong weight of love, our shepherd himself of warns us about good shepherds in the gospel. He warns us that we should not place out hope even in them because of their good works but that we should glorify our Father who is in heaven, the one who made them such, and he warns us about bad shepherds, whom he chose to indicate by the terms “scribes” and “Pharisees,” those who teach what is right but do what is wrong.

In commenting on the party spirit among the Corinthians (I belong to Peter! I belong to Paul!), Augustine wrote:

From this we understand that good shepherds do not seek their own interests but those of Jesus Christ and, that though good sheep imitate the actions of their good shepherds, they nonetheless do not put their hope in those by whose ministry they were gathered into the flock but rather in the Lord by whose blood they were redeemed. In that way, when they happen to come upon bad shepherds preaching Christ’s doctrine but doing their own evil deeds, they do what bad shepherds say, but they do not do what they do.

Legionaries have appealed to Augustine’s critique of Donatism to justify remaining in the Legion. The situations however are not exactly parallel. Leaving the Legion is not the same as abandoning the unity of the church; if Legionaries think that, they have a serious problem. Much of what Maciel taught is standard if somewhat old-fashioned Catholicism; if the Legionaries what to follow that, there is no problem. But Maciel insisted over and over again that the Legionaries imitate him: a hypocrite, thief, and child molester.

The cult of personality that has afflicted the Church, to which John Paul II contributed, is the source of the problem. I am for John Paul, I am for Maciel, I am for Küng! Catholics do not seem content with Jesus Christ as the model to be imitated but too often look for messiahs closer at hand.

Leave a Comment
«< 61 62 63 64 65 >»

Subscribe


 

Categories

RECENT ENTRIES

  • The Hands That Restored Notre Dame
  • Misinformation c. 1900
  • The Spirits Among Us
  • (no title)
  • Jewish Safety in Europe, East and West
  • Unamuno and the Eternal Journey into God
  • Unamuno and Universal Salvation
  • Recovery
  • Elizabeth Lawrence Gilman
  • James H. Rutter

Blogroll

  • A Twitch Upon the Thread
  • Abuse Tracker
  • All Things Catholic
  • American Papist
  • Ampersand
  • Catholic and Enjoying It
  • Catholic Culture
  • Catholic Edition
  • Catholic Online
  • Christianity Today
  • Disputations
  • DotCommonweal
  • First Principles
  • First Things – On The Square
  • Front Porch Republic
  • GetReligion
  • InsideCatholic
  • Kath.net
  • Mere Comments
  • National Catholic Register
  • National Catholic Reporter
  • New Oxford Review
  • NovAntiqua
  • Patrick Madrid
  • Pontifications
  • Reditus a Chronicle of Aesthetic Christianity
  • Rod Dreher Crunchy Con
  • Ross Douthat
  • Stephenscom
  • The Catholic Thing
  • The Crossland Foundation
  • The Curious Gaze
  • Via Media
  • Whispers in the Loggia

Reviews and Comments of Podles' new book: SACRILEGE

  • Julia Duin, of The Washington Times, on Lee Podles’ Sacrilege
Leon J. Podles :: DIALOGUE
© Leon J. Podles :: DIALOGUE 2025
Powered by WordPress • Themify WordPress Themes

↑ Back to top